We’re reaching the end of October, which apparently means it’s Christmas Time in Theatreland. Thus, festive shows galore are ushered in, bringing good cheer to the masses. As Debbie Isitt’s iconic film Nativity! has become a staple of our family’s Winter entertainment, I was rather intrigued by the announcement of a musical adaptation a while back. Fast forward to the present day, and this new retelling is finally on stage.
Before reviewing the show, I must say stress that my issues with it do not lie with the cast. Energetic, charismatic and always engaging to watch, the ensemble is phenomenal and they deliver strong performances. In particular, the chemistry between Mr Maddens and Mr Poppy (Daniel Boys and Simon Lipkin) makes their scenes a delight to watch. I must also stress that the choreography, direction and the live band are excellent too. What is on display is a refined and visually pleasing production that has clearly been laboured over. The children have been cast well, and also move with great purpose.
I believe the biggest problem with this musical is the writing. While the adaptation maintains the plot from this popular modern classic, extending it with songs and additional dialogue makes it feel rather bloated. What puzzles me here is that although the script was extended, many of the film’s best moments were cut from the show completely.
Musically, the writing is also disappointing. Asides from the numbers integral to the original film, the music is easily forgettable, despite being performed well. Characters seem to burst into song for no reason, other than that it’s time for another song. Tied together with artificial heart-string moments, Nativity! The Musical is entertaining and often amusing, but it comes across as obvious pandering and relies on the cast and crew to redeem it.
Productions like the RSC’s musical adaption of Matilda have set a high standard for shows with or about children and quite rightly so. With more time and attention spent on the writing, Nativity! The Musical could easily have been a five-star show as well. ★★★☆☆ Jeremy Ulster 26th October 2017
Photo Credit: The Other Richard
